Is This Therapy or Spirituality? What Happens When All of Modern Psychology Points Toward Ancient Wisdom
A contemplative look at the scientific convergence between evidence-based therapy and contemplative practice
Bradley Bemis | 6 November 2025
You might be wondering: is this guy a therapist or a spiritual teacher?
When you encounter language about "nondual awareness" and "contemplative wisdom" alongside clinical credentials and evidence-based practice, it's natural to ask: which one is it? Can someone really be both? And more importantly—if you're in real pain, will this actually help you?
Here's what's actually happening: every major evidence-based therapy developed in the last fifty years—CBT, DBT, ACT, IFS—along with breakthroughs in neuroscience and psychophysiology, keeps arriving at the same insights. And those insights? They're not new. They're what contemplatives have been teaching for thousands of years.
This isn't about mixing therapy with spirituality. It's about recognizing that when therapy works, it's facilitating the same fundamental shifts in consciousness that contemplative practices have always cultivated. We now have the science to prove it.
The Convergence: Multiple Paths, Same Destination
Something remarkable has been unfolding in psychology over the past several decades. Different researchers, working independently, investigating different problems, have all started arriving at strikingly similar conclusions about what actually helps people heal and thrive.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy taught us that thoughts shape experience and that we can change our relationship to thoughts. Dialectical Behavior Therapy taught us radical acceptance, distress tolerance, and the dialectic between acceptance and change. Acceptance and Commitment Therapy taught us psychological flexibility, defusion, and values-based living. Internal Family Systems taught us that beneath our protective parts lies an essential Self—curious, compassionate, calm. Neuroscience is showing us the brain mechanisms underlying all of this. And psychophysiology is proving that healing requires the body, not just the mind.
This isn't coincidence. This is science discovering what contemplatives intuited through millennia of direct investigation into the nature of consciousness and suffering.
CBT: Where the Modern Story Begins
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy revolutionized psychotherapy by demonstrating something that seems almost obvious now but was radical at the time: thoughts aren't facts; they're mental events. The way we think about our experience shapes our emotional response to it. More importantly, we can learn to observe our thinking process itself—what researchers call metacognitive awareness.
The evidence base for CBT is massive. Hundreds of randomized controlled trials, decades of research, effectiveness demonstrated across virtually every diagnostic category. When Aaron Beck started investigating the cognitive patterns underlying depression, he discovered something fundamental about how human minds create and maintain suffering.
But here's what's fascinating: cognitive restructuring—the practice of questioning and reframing distorted thoughts—works not primarily by producing more accurate thoughts, but by creating psychological distance from thoughts. The therapeutic mechanism isn't really about replacing "I'm worthless" with "I have value." It's about recognizing that "I'm worthless" is a thought, not a truth. It's about the space that opens up when you can observe a thought rather than being consumed by it.
This is precisely what Buddhist psychology has taught for 2,500 years. Thoughts arise and pass like clouds. They're not solid, not permanent, not who you are. Cognitive fusion—believing that thoughts are reality—creates suffering. The liberation comes from recognizing that you are the sky, not the clouds. You are the awareness in which thoughts appear, not the thoughts themselves.
The Shift That Changes Everything
Early CBT focused on changing the content of thoughts. But as the approach evolved through its "third wave," something shifted. Researchers realized: it's not about having better thoughts; it's about changing your relationship to thoughts entirely. The science was catching up to what contemplatives already knew.
DBT: Dialectics, Distress, and Radical Acceptance
When Marsha Linehan developed Dialectical Behavior Therapy for borderline personality disorder and severe emotion dysregulation, she brought something explicitly contemplative into mainstream psychology. Linehan had spent time in a Zen monastery, and it shows in the bones of DBT.
The core skills of DBT—mindfulness, distress tolerance, emotion regulation, interpersonal effectiveness—are all pointing at the same fundamental capacity: the ability to be present with intense, difficult, even seemingly unbearable experience without dissociating, acting impulsively, or self-destructing.
Radical acceptance, one of DBT's central concepts, is precisely what contemplatives mean by surrendering to what is. Not resignation. Not passive tolerance. Not giving up on change. But a full, embodied meeting with reality as it actually is in this moment, even when it's excruciating. This is one of the great paradoxes of healing: we can only change what we first accept completely.
The dialectic itself—holding both acceptance AND change simultaneously—mirrors the contemplative paradox: awakening to what is AND engaging fully with life. Neither spiritual bypassing (transcending the mess) nor drowning in reactivity (being the mess), but presence with the full catastrophe of being human while still choosing how to respond.
And Wise Mind—the integration of emotion mind and rational mind—is the recognition of awareness itself. That place beyond emotional reactivity or cognitive rigidity where we can be present with both thinking and feeling without being hijacked by either. Every contemplative tradition has a name for this: Buddha-mind, Christ-consciousness, the witness, the observing self, presence.
ACT: Psychological Flexibility as Awakened Living
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy makes the contemplative connection even more explicit. ACT's six core processes—cognitive defusion, acceptance, present moment awareness, self-as-context, values, and committed action—read like a map of contemplative practice translated into clinical language.
Cognitive defusion is the practice of seeing thoughts as thoughts rather than as reality. "I am having the thought that I'm a failure" creates a fundamentally different relationship to experience than "I am a failure." This isn't just semantic—it's a shift in the locus of identity. From being the content of consciousness to being consciousness itself. This is witnessing awareness, the observing self, the space in which experience arises.
Acceptance in ACT means willingness to have your experience as it is, without struggling to change it or push it away. Not because you like it, but because fighting with reality creates a secondary layer of suffering on top of the primary pain. This is the contemplative teaching of non-resistance: what we resist persists; what we can be with transforms.
Self-as-context is perhaps ACT's most radical contribution. It points to the recognition that you are not the story you tell about yourself, not the sum of your thoughts and feelings, not your history or your symptoms. You are the context in which all of that appears. The space. The awareness. What contemplatives call your true nature, your Buddha-nature, the Self with a capital S.
The research on ACT is extensive: hundreds of RCTs across every diagnostic category you can name. Meta-analyses showing that psychological flexibility—the core process ACT targets—predicts wellbeing, resilience, and quality of life. The science proves that this way of being with experience is what actually helps people. Not symptom elimination. Not positive thinking. But the capacity to have your experience fully while still choosing your actions freely.
IFS: Parts and the Essential Self
Internal Family Systems brings us even closer to explicit recognition of what contemplatives have always known. When Dick Schwartz asked his clients to step back and observe their parts—the anxious part, the angry part, the protective part—something unexpected emerged. When people could "unblend" from their parts and observe them with curiosity, they spontaneously accessed a different quality of consciousness.
Schwartz called it Self. And he found it had consistent qualities, what he came to call the 8 C's: curiosity, compassion, calm, clarity, courage, confidence, creativity, connectedness. This wasn't something he invented or taught—it emerged organically when people could get some space from their reactive patterns and protective strategies.
What Schwartz discovered through clinical observation is precisely what every contemplative tradition teaches: beneath the conditioned self, beneath the ego structure, beneath all the ways we've learned to protect ourselves and navigate the world, there is an essential nature. Awareness itself. Presence. The Self that is not constructed, not wounded, not in need of healing—because it was never broken.
IFS shows us that healing doesn't come from fixing the wounded parts. It comes from those parts learning to trust Self to lead. When we're in Self-energy—when we're connected to this essential awareness—we can be with our parts' pain without being overwhelmed by it. We can meet trauma with compassion rather than retraumatization. We can hold complexity without fragmenting.
The Recognition That Changes Everything
In Buddhist psychology, this is Buddha-nature. In Christian mysticism, it's the Christ within. In Hinduism, it's atman. In secular contemplative language, it's simply awareness, presence, consciousness itself. Different names for the same recognition: there is something beneath the conditioned self, and touching it is healing.
Neuroscience: Measuring the Mechanisms of Awakening
Now we can watch these processes unfold in the brain itself. Decades of neuroimaging research—fMRI, EEG, structural imaging—have given us unprecedented insight into what happens neurologically when people meditate, when therapy works, when psychological flexibility increases.
The Default Mode Network is particularly revealing. The DMN—a network of brain regions including the medial prefrontal cortex and posterior cingulate cortex—is most active when we're lost in thought, ruminating, constructing narratives about ourselves, worrying about the future or rehashing the past. It's the neural signature of identification with the thinking mind, of being caught in the story of "me."
Depression, anxiety, and PTSD all show overactive DMN function. People suffering from these conditions are literally stuck in their thoughts about themselves and their experience. And here's what's remarkable: both meditation and effective psychotherapy decrease DMN activity. When you practice defusion, radical acceptance, or access Self-energy, the DMN quiets. You shift from being the story to being the awareness that observes the story.
Psychedelics: Rapid Access to Non-Dual Recognition
The research on psychedelics and the Default Mode Network reveals something particularly striking about how experiential insight happens. Studies using fMRI to track brain activity during psilocybin, LSD, and ayahuasca sessions show dramatic, temporary decreases in DMN activity—often far more pronounced than what's seen even in experienced meditators.
What happens subjectively when the DMN quiets so dramatically? People report what researchers call "ego dissolution"—a temporary loss of the sense of being a separate, boundaried self. The usual feeling of "I" as distinct from everything else dissolves. People describe merging with their surroundings, a sense of unity, profound interconnectedness, the dissolution of the subject-object divide. They're having direct, unmediated experience of what contemplatives call non-dual awareness.
This isn't people thinking differently about themselves. It's not a new belief system or philosophical perspective. It's experiential contact with a different mode of consciousness entirely—one in which the constructed sense of a separate self temporarily goes offline, revealing what was always already there beneath it.
The therapeutic research on psychedelics is remarkable. Studies at Johns Hopkins, Imperial College London, MAPS, and elsewhere show significant, sustained improvements in depression, anxiety, PTSD, and addiction following psychedelic-assisted therapy. But here's what's particularly revealing: the degree of therapeutic benefit correlates strongly with the depth of what's called the "mystical experience"—the ego-dissolving, unity-consciousness, ineffable quality of the session.
In other words, healing doesn't come primarily from the pharmacology. It comes from the experience itself—the direct recognition of consciousness without the usual sense of a separate, defended self. People touch something that contemplatives have been pointing toward for millennia, and it changes them. They realize experientially, not intellectually, that they are not the story they've been telling about themselves. They feel in their bones that the separate self is constructed, not fundamental.
This is why psychedelic experiences can be so therapeutic: they provide experiential access to what years of meditation or therapy might gradually reveal. They temporarily quiet the DMN so completely that people can directly recognize what they are beneath the thinking mind, beneath the narrative self, beneath all the protective strategies and identifications.
But—and this is crucial—the insight needs integration. A profound psychedelic experience can open a door, but you still have to learn to live through that door. This is where therapy becomes essential. The recognition that happened in the session needs to be integrated into daily life, embodied in relationships, metabolized through the nervous system. Without integration, even profound experiences can fade or remain isolated from ordinary consciousness.
This is what psychedelic integration therapy does: it helps bridge the experiential insight from the session into sustainable psychological flexibility in everyday life. It helps people understand what they experienced, work with what emerged, and gradually embody the recognition over time. The psychedelic experience can catalyze the shift; therapy helps make it lasting.
Meanwhile, meditation and therapy strengthen the prefrontal cortex and its regulatory connections to the amygdala and other limbic structures. This is the neuroscience of emotion regulation and cognitive flexibility—the brain's capacity to feel intensely without being hijacked, to notice reactivity without acting it out, to respond rather than react. This is measurable psychological flexibility at the neural level.
The insula, responsible for interoceptive awareness—the ability to sense what's happening inside your body—shows increased activation and connectivity in both meditators and therapy clients who improve. Trauma survivors often have disrupted insula function; they can't feel their bodies accurately. They're dissociated, numbed, cut off from felt experience. Healing requires restoring this interoceptive awareness, this capacity to be present in the body. And we can measure it happening.
Perhaps most striking is the research on neuroplasticity. The brain physically changes through experience. Meditation produces measurably thicker cortex in areas associated with attention and interoceptive awareness. It increases hippocampal volume, important for memory and emotion regulation. It decreases amygdala reactivity. Therapy creates new neural pathways. The science shows us that healing isn't just psychological—it's literally structural. The brain reorganizes itself through sustained practice of presence, acceptance, and responsiveness.
Psychophysiology: The Body as the Doorway
But this isn't just happening in the brain. It's happening in the entire nervous system, throughout the body. Stephen Porges' Polyvagal Theory has given us a map of how the autonomic nervous system responds to threat and safety. Three neural circuits: the ventral vagal system (social engagement, safety, connection), the sympathetic system (fight or flight), and the dorsal vagal system (freeze, shutdown, collapse).
Trauma gets locked in the body when we're stuck in sympathetic activation or dorsal shutdown. Healing requires restoring ventral vagal capacity—the felt sense of safety, the ability to be present and connected even when things are difficult. And here's what research shows: contemplative practice activates the ventral vagal system. Meditation doesn't just change your thoughts about stress—it changes your nervous system's response to stress.
Dan Siegel's concept of the window of tolerance describes this beautifully. We each have a range within which we can process experience without becoming dysregulated—neither hyperaroused nor hypoaroused, neither flooded nor numbed. Trauma narrows this window. Healing expands it. And both therapy and contemplative practice work by gradually increasing the nervous system's capacity to remain present with intensity.
This is measurable. Heart rate variability—the variation in time between heartbeats—is an index of vagal tone and autonomic flexibility. Higher HRV correlates with resilience, emotional regulation, and the capacity to respond rather than react. And meditation increases HRV. We can literally measure contemplative practice in the body.
Peter Levine's Somatic Experiencing and Bessel van der Kolk's work on trauma have made it undeniable: healing from trauma requires the body. Trauma is stored as incomplete survival responses in the nervous system. You can't think your way out of it. You have to feel your way through it—carefully, titrated, with support—completing the responses that got frozen in the moment of overwhelm.
This is why contemplative traditions have always been embodied practices. Not just sitting and thinking about the nature of mind, but breath, sensation, posture, movement. Yoga, tai chi, qigong, walking meditation. The body is the doorway to presence. And modern psychophysiology proves it.
The Synthesis: One Understanding, Many Languages
Can you see the pattern now? All of these approaches—CBT, DBT, ACT, IFS, neuroscience, psychophysiology, and psychedelic-assisted therapy—are describing the same fundamental shifts in consciousness:
From identification to awareness. From being lost in thoughts and feelings to being able to observe thoughts and feelings. From "I am anxious" to "anxiety is present." From fusion to defusion, from immersion to witnessing, from DMN dominance to quiet awareness. Psychedelics can temporarily dissolve this identification so completely that people experience directly what contemplatives mean by "no-self"—not as a concept, but as lived reality. This is what every contemplative tradition points toward: the recognition that you are not your thoughts; you are the awareness in which thoughts appear.
From avoidance to presence. From trying to control, suppress, or escape difficult experience to being willing to have your experience as it is. From experiential avoidance to acceptance, from distress intolerance to distress tolerance, from dissociation to interoception, from sympathetic activation to ventral vagal engagement. This is the contemplative teaching of non-resistance, of radical allowing, of meeting what is with compassion rather than warfare.
From fragmentation to integration. From being pulled apart by conflicting parts, thoughts, and emotions to finding coherence. From being hijacked by reactivity to psychological flexibility, from emotion mind versus rational mind to Wise Mind, from parts in conflict to parts trusting Self, from prefrontal-limbic dysregulation to integration. This is the wholeness that every tradition speaks of—not perfection, but integration.
From reactivity to responsiveness. From being controlled by automatic patterns to being able to choose. From stimulus-response conditioning to values-aligned action, from narrow window of tolerance to expanded capacity, from hyperarousal or hypoarousal to presence in the middle. This is freedom—not the absence of difficulty, but the capacity to respond to difficulty with wisdom and compassion.
From disembodiment to embodiment. From being cut off from felt experience to being present in the body. From alexithymia to interoception, from dissociation to somatic awareness, from low HRV to high HRV, from abstract understanding to lived, felt knowing. This is the insistence of every authentic contemplative path: it must be embodied, felt, lived—not just understood.
These aren't five separate processes. They're five facets of the same transformation. Different languages pointing at the same shift. And that shift is what effective therapy facilitates. It's also what contemplative practice cultivates. Because they were never two different things.
Why This Integration Makes Me a Better Therapist
So when you ask: is this therapy or spiritual teaching? The answer is: that's a false dichotomy.
What I offer is evidence-based therapy—I use CBT, DBT, ACT, IFS, all rigorously researched, all proven effective across hundreds of studies. I'm trained in the protocols, I follow the evidence, I track outcomes, I maintain professional standards and ethical boundaries.
I'm informed by neuroscience and psychophysiology—I understand polyvagal theory, window of tolerance, the neurobiology of trauma, how the Default Mode Network functions, how interoceptive awareness develops, how healing happens in the nervous system and not just in conscious thought.
And I'm grounded in contemplative wisdom—I understand that what we're cultivating isn't just "coping skills," but fundamental shifts in consciousness that traditions have been teaching for millennia. I know that psychological flexibility, Wise Mind, Self-energy, metacognitive awareness, and witnessing consciousness are different names for the same capacity. I've lived it, practiced it, and continue to deepen it in my own life.
This integration doesn't make my work less rigorous—it makes it more precise.
When I guide you into cognitive defusion, I'm not just teaching you an ACT technique. I'm helping you recognize the nature of thought itself—that thoughts are mental events, not reality; that you are the space in which thoughts arise, not the thoughts themselves.
When we work with radical acceptance, I'm not just doing DBT skills training. I'm facilitating the capacity for true meeting with experience—the recognition that resistance creates suffering and that allowing creates space for transformation.
When we explore your parts, I'm not just following an IFS protocol. I'm helping you discover the Self that was always there beneath the protective strategies—the awareness that is curious, compassionate, calm, and was never broken.
When we work with the body—breath, sensation, the felt sense of being here now—I'm not just doing somatic therapy. I'm helping you restore interoceptive awareness, expand your window of tolerance, shift from sympathetic activation to ventral vagal safety. I'm helping you come home to your body.
When we work with psychedelic integration, I'm not adding something fringe or unscientific. I'm helping you metabolize and embody the experiential insights that emerged during your journey—the same recognition of non-dual awareness that meditation cultivates gradually over years, but accessed rapidly through the temporary quieting of the Default Mode Network. The science on psychedelic-assisted therapy is rigorous and growing; integration ensures those insights become lasting transformation rather than isolated experiences.
I'm doing evidence-based therapy with a deeper understanding of what it's actually facilitating. And the science proves it works—not because I added something extra, but because effective therapy has always been about facilitating these shifts. We just didn't always know how to name them.
The Practical Wisdom of Being Human
For thousands of years, contemplatives sat in caves and monasteries discovering these truths through direct investigation of consciousness. They mapped the terrain of human suffering and freedom with extraordinary precision. And now, we have CBT, DBT, ACT, IFS, neuroscience, and psychophysiology all converging on the same insights through completely independent pathways.
This isn't abstract philosophy. This is practical, lived, embodied wisdom about how to be with the full catastrophe of being human—with pain, with joy, with trauma, with wonder, with all of it—without being destroyed by it. It's about cultivating the capacity to feel deeply without being overwhelmed, to think clearly without being imprisoned by thought, to be present with difficulty without dissociating or acting out.
The ancient contemplatives were phenomenologists of consciousness. They investigated the nature of mind and suffering with the rigor of any scientist. Modern psychology is finally catching up, arriving at the same conclusions through controlled studies, brain scans, and clinical trials.
And the beautiful thing? You don't need to sit in a cave for twenty years. You don't need to adopt any religious framework or believe anything on faith. You don't need to choose between science and wisdom, between therapy and spirituality.
You just need to learn what every evidence-based therapy is teaching: how to be present with your experience, how to hold it with compassion, how to recognize that you are not your thoughts or feelings but the awareness that knows them, how to choose actions aligned with what matters most to you, even when it's hard.
This is therapy. This is science. This is wisdom.
They were never separate.
~From the Heart of Bradley
Ready to Explore Your Own Journey?
If this integration of evidence-based therapy and contemplative wisdom speaks to you, I invite you to reach out. Together, we can explore what healing and transformation might look like for you.
Begin the ConversationIn Crisis? You're Not Alone
If you're in immediate danger or experiencing a mental health emergency, please reach out for support right away:
- 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: Call or text 988
- Crisis Text Line: Text HOME to 741741
- Colorado Crisis Services: 1-844-493-8255 (24/7)
- Emergency: Call 911 or go to your nearest emergency room